NAS REPORT ON FORENSIC SCIENCE & CRIME LABS
“The truth is that promoting science isn’t just about providing resources—it’s about protecting free and open
inquiry. It’s about ensuring that facts and evidence are never twisted or obscured by politics or ideology." -
President Obama (Radio address on Dec20, 2008
MEDIA COVERAGE, COMMENTS & RESPONSES
NAS REPORT
You can buy the hard copy or download PDF file
Forensic Science Reform:FEDERAL OVERSIGHT AND STANDARDS FOR FORENSIC SCIENCE
Strengthening Forensic Science in the United States:
A Path Forward - Report from the National Research Council-'Badly Fragmented' Forensic Science System Needs Overhaul-
Listen to the Briefing
Read Full Report online(254 pages)
NAS Report: Strengthening Forensic Science in the United States: A Path Forward:
41-page Executive Summary
'Badly fragmented' forensic science
system needs overhaul (Public release by NAS)
NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF FORENSIC SCIENCE
(NIFS): LEGISLATIVE OUTLINE (Draft)
U.S. House of
Representatives: Committee on Science and Technology: Subcommittee on Technology
and Innovation: Hearing on March 10, 2009
Subcommittee on Technology
and Innovation
HEARING CHARTER
SUBCOMMITTEE EXPLORES FORENSIC SCIENCE NEEDS
US Congress
Investigates Forensic Science Requirements
Opening Statement: The Honorable Adrian Smith, Ranking Member
Statement of Peter M. Marone Director, Virginia Department
of Forensic Science
Statement of Carol E. Henderson, Professor, Stetson
University College of Law and Director, The National Clearinghouse for Science,
Technology and the Law
Statement of John W. Hicks
TESTIMONY OF PETER NEUFELD CO-DIRECTOR, THE INNOCENCE
PROJECT
Statement
of James Claude Upshaw Downs, MD, Forensic Pathologist/Consultant, Georgia Bureau of Investigation
Senate Judiciary Committee Hearings
Hearing on March 18, 2009
Hearing before the Senate Judiciary Committee
Statement of The Honorable
Senator Patrick Leahy, Chairman
An open letter from ASCLD to Senator Patrick Leahy
Statement of The Honorable Judge Harry T.
Edwards, Co-Chair, Committee on Identifying the Needs of the Forensic Science Community
Comments of Senator Jay Rockefeller, the chairman of the
Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Transportation and Rep. John Conyers, the chairman of the U.S. House of
Represenatives Judiciary Committee
Hearing on September 9, 2009
Official Hearing Notice/Witness List)
Statement Of Senator Patrick Leahy
(D-Vt.), Chairman, Senate Judiciary Committee
Statement of U.S. Senator Russell D.
Feingold, Wisconsin
Statement of The Honorable
Al Franken, Senator, Minnesota
Testimony of Eric Buel, Ph.D., Director,
Vermont Forensic Laboratory
TESTIMONY OF PETER NEUFELD, CO-DIRECTOR,
THE INNOCENCE PROJECT
Testimony of Matthew F. Redle,
County and Prosecuting Attorney, Sheridan County, Wyoming
Testimony of Barry D. Matson,
Deputy Director, Alabama District Attorneys Association, Chief Prosecutor, Alabama Computer Forensics Laboratories,
Montgomery, AL
Testimony of Harold L. Hurt, Chief of
Police, City of Houston, TX
STATEMENT OF PAUL C. GIANNELLI,
WEATHERHEAD PROFESSOR OF LAW, CASE WESTERN RESERVE UNIVERSITY
National Science and Technology Council (
NSTC)
National Science and Technology
Council Committee on Science: Subcommittee on Forensic Science: Initial Overview Briefing
CHARTER of the
SUBCOMMITTEE ON FORENSIC SCIENCE COMMITTEE ON SCIENCE NATIONAL SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY COUNCIL
Working at OSTP: Forensic Science (OSTP Blog)
NSTC Subcommittee on Forensic Science
and Forensics Working Groups
Forensic Science, Research,
Development, Testing & Evaluation (Jeff Salyards Program Manager, Science and Technology, U.S. Army Criminal
Investigations Laboratory
RESPONSES & COMMENTS
The American Academy of Forensic
Sciences (AAFS) Comments on National Academy of Sciences' 'Forensic Needs' Report
ASCLD’s Comments on the Release of the
NAS Report on Forensic Science
CFSO Calls for Roundtable to Develop
National Strategy for Advancing Forensic Sciences in the United States
The Forensic Specialties
Accreditation Board's Comments on the NAS Report
The American Board of Forensic Toxicology (ABFT) response to NAS report
The Society of Forensic Toxicologists Comments on the NAS report
SWGFAST Comments on NAS report
Statement From Matthew A. Miller, Director of the Office of Public Affairs (NIJ/DOJ)
Peter Neufeld, Barry Scheck & Madeline deLone
(Innocence Project) letter to Laurie Robinson, DOJ Presidential Transition Team about creation of a “National
Institute of Forensic Science”
Legacy of historic document depends on
good-faith collaboration (Special Report-Crime Lab Report) - Excellent Review
FORENSIC SCIENCE OVERSIGHT AND POLICY DEVELOPMENT: LESSONS
FROM NEW YORK AND OBSERVATIONS ABOUT THE COMING NEW ERA OF FORENSIC SCIENCE REFORM (Barry Scheck)
RESPONSE FROM LAW ASSOCIATIONS & LAW JOURNALS
Solving the Problems That Plague the Forensic Science Community (Keynote
Address at Comference by the Homorable Harry T. Eswards
Draft Report Condemns Shoddy Practices at Many Crime Labs (American Bar Association Journal)
Statement from the National District Attorneys
Association Regarding the NAS report
National Academy of Sciences Finds
Serious Deficiencies' in Nation's Crime Labs (National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (NACDL))
Crime Labs
in Disarray Nationally; Reform, Independence Needed, Report Says (American Bar Association Journal)
National report finds forensic science
labs underfunded, understaffed and without proper oversight (The National Law Journal)
National Academy of Science Report on Crime Lab Deficiencies, Office of Indigent Defence Services, North Carolina
Junk Science Used To Decide Defendants’ Fates
by NORM PATTIS (Connecticut Law Tribune)
National Academies of Science: Trust Nothing (USLaw.com)
Crime Lab Closures Lead to Backlogs while Report Set to
Criticize Widely Used Forensic Techniques (FindLaw)
NAS report to be 'force of change in forensic field' (Sandra Day O'Connor
College of Law, ASU (“Forensic Science for the 21st Century: The National Academy of Sciences Report and Beyond.”-
Conference
Setting forensic science on a new path (American Judicature Society)
Defense Counsel View Report as New Weapon (LAW.COM)
COVERAGE ON TV
Crime labs are seriously deficient, report says
(MSNBC)
Crime labs need major overhaul, study
finds (CNN)
New Report Calls for Forensic Science Reform
(KLAS-TV: Los Vegas)
Man blames science
for nearly 20 years he spent in prison (CNN.com)
COVERAGE ON RADIO
Crime Labs and Dismal Science: One Hour Radio
show with Judge Harry Edwards, Barry Scheck, Barry Fisher & Prof. James Doyle (NPR: On Point)
Call For Forensics Overhaul Linked To
'CSI' Effect (Listen Now:4min 15sec)(NPR)
Crime Labs and Dismal Science (NPR)
Report: Forensics Rife With 'Serious
Problems' ((Listen Now:4min 6sec)(NPR)
Foolproof Forensics? The Jury Is Still
Out (NPR)
Forensic Fact Checking (WCPN 90.3FM/NPR)
COVERAGE IN WIRESERVICES,
NEWSPAPERS & MAGAZINES
Report:
Real-world CSI's lack consistent standards-By DEVLIN BARRETT (AP)
U.S. forensic crime labs need
major reform: experts (Reuters)
Study: Forensics rely on flawed science (UPI)
US forensic science
needs total overhaul: study (AFP)
Study Calls for Oversight of Forensics in Crime Labs
(New York Times)
Science Found Wanting in Nation’s Crime Labs
(New York Times)
Crime Scene Imperfections (New York Times
Editorial)
Plugging Holes in the Science of Forensics
(New York Times)
Clueless 'science' (Los Angels Times-Opinion
by Jennifer L. Mnookin, professor and vice dean at UCLA Law School)
Report questions science,
reliability of crime lab evidence (Los Angels Times)
L.A. Times on Forensics Reform
Report: Real-world police forensics
don't resemble 'CSI' (USA Today)
Evidence Of Injustice:
FBI's Bullet Lead Analysis Used Flawed Science To Convict Hundreds Of Defendants (60 Minutes/The Washington Post
Joint Investigation)
High Court to Hear
DNA Testing Case: Justices to Debate Whether Convicts Should Be Guaranteed Access to Latest Techniques (The
Washington Post)
Federal report finds deficiencies in use of forensics in
criminal cases(Post-Gazette.com)
Lab Analyst Decision
Complicates Prosecutions: High Court Requires Scientists to Testify
Real-world CSI in
question (Chicago Tribune)
Some techniques long suspect(Chicago Tribune)
Cross-Examining Forensics (Radley Balco)(Jackson Free Press)
The science that
isn't (The Globe and Mail, Canada)
Ottawa urged to establish forensics watchdog(The Star.Com, Canada)
FBI lab in serious trouble (Canada Free Press)
Report calls for overhaul
of U.S. crime-lab system (The Seattle Times)
National
agency sought for forensic sciences (The Arizona Republic)
Study calls crime lab system into
question; overhaul sought (Mercury News)
Houston: They all have a problem
(Commentary: Houston Chronicle)
Improving forensic science
(Los Vegas Sun)
Junk science or not?
(Editorial: Baltimore Sun)
Forensic science, a misnomer (Our View: Baltimore Sun)
Forensic science not much science, study says
(Pittsburgh Post Gazette)
Report criticizes U.S. crime labs (The Daily Iowan)
Forensic "evidence" ain't what it's cracked up to be (Orlando Sentinel)
Establish independent forensic labs (Herald-Tribune)
Editorial: Screen out junk science (The Dallas Morning News)
Are Texas arsons a case of bad science? Some experts think so (The Dallas Morning News)
Trial by Fire: Did Texas execute an
innocent man? (The Newyorker)
Making forensic science more scientific
(Opinion: Nature)
Bitemark Evidence And Analysis Should
Be Approached With Caution, According To Study (ScienceDaily)
Forensics labs mostly using unproved science, report says (Scientific American)
Study: Separate Police, Labs Because of Bias (Lab Manager Magazine-
Las Vegas Sun)
The DNA Connection: The NAS Study - We should Begin at the
Beginning By: Chris Asplen
High Court Recognizes Imperfections at Crime Labs (Miller–McCune)
Verdict on Forensic Science: It’s Quite Bad (Discover Magazine)
Questionable Crime-Scene Science (C&EN)
Forensic
science 'too unreliable', says report (NewScientist)
The National Academy of Sciences Identifying the Needs of the Forensic
Science Community (Crime Lab Report)
Taylor and Francis's "Forensic Science Policy and
Management Journal" article defends forensic science
'Badly Fragmented' Forensic Science
System Needs Overhaul (Science Daily)
NAS: Nation's Forensic Sciences Need Overhaul (Security Management)
NEW REPORT FROM THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES CALLS FOR SIGNIFICANT CHANGES IN THE
UNITED STATES FORENSIC-SCIENCE COMMUNITY (Evidence Technology Magazine)
Supreme Court Requires Lab Analysts to Testify: Now
What?
Deficiencies in Forensic Science Training Must Be Met Head-On: Scientists, Lawyers, and Judges Need Education to Overcome the
“CSI Effect” (Richard E. Bisbing in Genetic Engineering & Biotechnology News
Flawed forensics?
National report identifies areas that science must redress and refurbish (Officer.Com)
The Truth About 4 Common Forensics
Methods (Popular Mechanics)
CSI Myths: The Shaky Science
Behind Forensics (Popular Mechanics)
Forensic Friday:
The Death Quiz (The Crime Lab Project)
Forensic Science on Trial:
The First of Two ScienceInsider Interviews (SCience Magazine)
Forensic Science on Trial:
Part Two (SCience Magazine)
INNOCENSE PROJECT
Peter Neufeld, Barry Scheck & Madeline deLone
(Innocence Project) letter to Laurie Robinson, DOJ Presidential Transition Team about creation of a “National
Institute of Forensic Science”
Major U.S. Report Calls for “Massive Overhaul” of Forensics
(Innocense Project)
National Academy of Sciences Urges Comprehensive Reform
of U.S. Forensic Sciences (Innocense Project)
Reactions to Groundbreaking National Academy of Sciences
Report Urging Reform in U.S. Forensic Sciences (Innocense Project)
Understanding the Causes: Unvalidated or Improper Forensic Science (Innocense
Project)
Fix the System: Forensic Oversight
(Innocense Project)
The myths behind forensic science (Innocense Project o Florida)
COVERAGE ON INTERNET
THE NAS REPORT ON FORENSIC SCIENCE: A FORENSIC SCIENTIST’S
RESPONSE by Brent E. Turvey
Government-Funded Study Calls for Overhaul of Nation’s Crime Labs by Ben Protess, ProPublica
Forensic Science on Trial:Part I-
Interview with John Lentini (ScienceInsider-AAFS)
Forensic Science on Trial:Part II-Interview with Jay Siegel, director of the Forensic and Investigative Sciences
Program at Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis (ScienceInsider-AAFS)
Just how scientific is forensic science? (Chicago Now.Com)
Manufacturing Guilt? (Radley Balko in ReasonOnLine)
In Criminal Cases, Should Science Only Serve the State?
(Radley Balko in ReasonOnLine)
C.S.Oy: Forensic science is badly in need of reform. Here are some
suggestions.(By Radley Balko and Roger Koppl: Slate)
'Badly Fragmented' Forensic Science
System Needs Overhaul (sciencedaily.com)
Science Found Wanting In Nation's Crime Labs (
FreeInternetPress)
USDOJ should embrace,
not fight science-based forensics (Grits for Breakfast)
US justice system
ommonly relies on shoddy forensic "science" (Grits for Breakfast)
The Long-Awaited
Call for Forensic Science Reform (The Justice Project Blog)
Forensic Science System Needs Overhaul
(livescience.com)
The Future of Forensic Science: UB Researcher Contributes to
National Report
Re-Mapping Forensic
Science’s Future (Miller–McCune.com)
Compromised crime laboratories
are a national scandal that can't be set straight until the labs are independent of law enforcement
(Miller–McCune.com)
Arson Convictions, Fire Investigations Feel the Heat (Miller–McCune.com)
Report: Crime
labs seriously deficient (Newsvine.com)
Government-Funded Study Calls for Major Overhaul of Nation's Crime Labs (AlterNet)
Report questions science, reliability of crime lab evidence (Cervantes)
Report: Crime Labs Lack Consistent Standards
(ClickOnDetroit)
Who Wants to Be a Coroner?
(Change.org)
Forensic Science Under Fire
(Forensic Science Blog, UF)
Yet another wrongful conviction misattributed to
faulty science (Crime Lab Report)
National Academy of
Sciences Urges Comprehensive Reform of U.S. Forensic Sciences
The National Academy of Science Has Been Perfecting
Double-speak (The LRC Blog)
Crime labs must work faster, be accurate.(Editorial-The Parthenon Online-
Marshal University)
Report Shows Flaws in America’s Crime Labs (findingDulcinea.com)
Forensic Evidence Under Attack (TalkLeft)
Forensic
science system flawed (Themoneytimes.com)
Report: U.S. forensic
science system direly needs to toned up (topnews.us)
Research Committee Recommends Overhaul of Crime Labs (associatedcontent.com)
NAS report on
the state of forensic science (The Defence Rests)
NAS Report Released (The StandDown
Texas Project)
Forensic Reform is Needed
Now (The Crime Report)
This is a new books/revised/new edition list published during 2009-2011 in all the areas of forensic science
listing over 300 books. For a complete list of books in speciality areas like
Forensic DNA ,
Fingerprints , visit individual pages or visit FORENSIC SCIENCE
BOOK STORE . You can buy these Forensic Science books at discount prices from Amazon.com.
Amazon.com Widgets
This list is of general forensic interest for students and professionals. For books in speciality areas like
Forensic DNA ,
Fingerprints , visit individual pages or visit FORENSIC SCIENCE
BOOK STORE . You can buy these Forensic Science books at discount prices from Amazon.com.
Amazon.com Widgets